Hi Dalton, welcome to the forum
Use a hotspot image for the 2 objects each, then you can use only 1 frame:
Rightclick the hotspot, and go to the General Tab of the Hotspot Properties, and look at the Hotspot Appearance part. Check "Picture" and import the image of the object (make sure that the background of the image is transparent).
Then go to the Action tab of the Hotspot Properties. Check the box "Hide and disable this hotspot (permanently)". This way, the object will be gone from the screen after the player has clicked it.
Then go to the Item tab of the Hotspot Properties, and check the box "When the hotspot is clicked, add an item to the inventory", choose/import an .ico image for the same object.
Do the same with your second hotspot/object.
(If you're not making a game for Windows, but for iPhone/iPodTouch, you can't work with inventory for now, but rather have to use variables.)
Hope that answers your question